Why Does Stamping Stress Raise Core Loss?
A sheared edge looks clean under a shop light, and it hides damage that reaches millimetres inward. Stamping stress raises loss through three zones, and each zone reaches a different depth. Jiangsu Zhongtong Weiye Special Steel Co., Ltd. maps that profile below, using a non-oriented electrical steel sheet as the example.
The Short Answer
Loss rises by roughly 5 to 10 percent after punching. The rise follows the edge share, rather than the tonnage. A narrow limb carries a larger edge share, so it pays more. Hence geometry decides the penalty, while the grade decides the starting point. The annealing note covers what a furnace can recover.
Zone One — The Cut Face
The fracture runs through the sheet, so the face itself carries bare metal and a rough profile. Four bands appear across that face, and each one behaves differently. A rounded entry, a bright band, a torn band, and a burr sit in sequence. Hence the face is not a clean plane, and a magnified view settles any argument. The burr note covers the last band.
Zone Two — The Distorted Band
Plastic flow reaches inward from the fracture, and dislocations multiply in that band. A band near one sheet thickness carries most of the damage, and its loss runs above the parent figure. That band also hardens, so it resists the next operation. Hence the damage is both magnetic and mechanical, since the same band does both jobs.
Zone Three — The Elastic Field
A wider field carries residual elastic strain at a lower intensity, and it extends further than the visible band. That field barely shows in a micrograph, yet it shifts the loss curve. It also relaxes over time, so a fresh core and an aged core read differently, as the aging note explains. Hence the third zone explains why a first test can mislead.
![]()
Why Narrow Limbs Suffer
Take a square lamination of 100 by 100 millimetres, and the edge band covers about 2 percent of its area. Take a strip of 10 by 100 millimetres, and the same band covers about 11 percent. The ratio reaches roughly 5.5 to 1, so the strip pays far more per unit of useful flux. Hence a motor tooth sits at the bad end of that scale. Its width runs near 5 to 8 millimetres. The motor note covers that case.
How Much Loss Rises
A punched core typically reads 5 to 10 percent above its material figure. The top of that range belongs to thin gauge. Thin strip carries proportionally more edge, so the same burr hurts more. A 0.20 mm sheet therefore suffers more than a 0.50 mm sheet, at equal geometry and equal die. Hence the thin grades deserve a sharper die and a tighter schedule.
Stress Is Not Uniform
Damage varies through the thickness, since the punch side and the die side meet differently. The punch side rolls over, and the die side tears, so the two faces differ in hardness and in burr. A stack also multiplies the effect, since aligned bands add up. Hence rotation spreads the damage, and it turns a sharp penalty into a mild one. The stacking note covers that rotation.
What Reverses It
Three levers lower the penalty, and each one acts at a different stage. A sharper die cuts a shorter distorted band, so maintenance pays before the press does. A relief cycle recovers part of the loss, since heat lets the lattice relax. Rotation spreads what remains across the stack. Hence the answer combines tooling, heat, and stacking, rather than any single fix.
A Die Log That Pays
A die log turns a vague penalty into a number, and it costs one page. Record the tonnage between regrinds, the burr height at each check, and the loss of the last sample. A trend then shows when the edge starts to cost watts. Hence a shop can regrind on evidence, rather than on a calendar. That habit also settles arguments with a supplier, since the log carries dates.
What Goes Wrong
One buyer blames the grade for a loss miss that a worn die caused. Another stamps a 5 millimetre tooth with a die set for 0.50 mm. A third skips rotation, so aligned bands stack into a column. Those three errors arrive monthly.
What We Do Not Do
We do not melt or roll steel. We do not regrind a customer’s die, since that work belongs to the tool room. Nor do we quote a punching penalty as a fixed percentage without the geometry.
Those limits keep the answer honest, and they keep a die budget honest too.
Specify Your Order
Give the limb width, the perimeter, the gauge, and the die clearance. Four fields then size the penalty. Add the annual volume, since die wear follows tonnage rather than calendar time. A grain oriented sheet covers a different duty. A silicon steel sheet covers a thicker build. That reply usually takes a day.
Related Reading
Our burr effect note covers the symptoms. The shear note covers the force. A hub page answers six basic questions.
Frequently Asked Questions
About 5 to 10 percent, and thin gauge sits at the top.
Near one sheet thickness, with a weaker field beyond.
Yes, since their edge share runs five times higher.
Yes, because it spreads aligned bands across the stack.
A sharper die shortens the band, so it helps first.
- Email: vera.liang@ztwysteel.com
- Location: Xishan District, Wuxi, Jiangsu, China
- Supply range: CRGO and CRNGO 0.20–0.65 mm, four coating classes
- Slitting: 20–1,250 mm, ±0.05 mm, burr under 0.02 mm
- Documentation: MTC EN 10204 3.1 with grade, thickness and loss basis, 3.2 on request