CRNGO M-15, M-19, M-27 and M-36: Grade Comparison
M-15, M-19, M-27 and M-36 still appear on North American motor drawings, repair lists and older equipment manuals, even though the current ASTM A677 specification no longer uses these designations. Reading them correctly matters when a replacement lamination has to match a motor that was specified decades ago. This note ranks the four grades by performance, explains what the M number does and does not mean, and sets out how to match an old M grade to a current designation. The material in question is non-oriented electrical steel, the family used in every rotating machine.
What the M Number Does and Does Not Mean
The first trap is reading the M number the way a Chinese or European grade number reads. In a designation such as 50W470 or M470-50A, the middle digits state the maximum core loss at a stated test point: 4.70 W/kg at 1.5 T, 50 Hz. The number carries the loss figure directly.
The old AISI M designations do not work that way. M-15, M-19, M-27 and M-36 are type labels within a thickness band, ordered from the lowest-loss grade to the highest-loss grade. The digits are not a loss value, and subtracting or comparing them across thicknesses does not produce a watts-per-kilogram figure. Two rules follow:
- The number rises as silicon content falls, core loss rises, stamping becomes easier and price drops.
- The same M type can exist in more than one thickness, and its loss figure changes with that thickness.
How CRNGO grade codes read covers the current W and EN systems in detail; the M series is the older North American side of the same comparison.
The Four Grades in Order
The table ranks the four from highest performance to lowest. The current-equivalent column shows the band a replacement would usually sit in, not a one-to-one name match.
| Old AISI grade | Position in the range | Common thickness | Typical use | Rough current-equivalent band |
| M-15 | Lowest loss of the four; highest silicon level | 0.36 mm | High-efficiency motors, generators | Near the M250-35A / 35W250 band |
| M-19 | Upper mid-range | 0.36, 0.47 mm | Efficient industrial motors, pumps | Near the M270-35A / 35W270 band |
| M-27 | General-purpose mid grade | 0.36, 0.47, 0.64 mm | Standard motors, fans, compressors | Mid 35W / 50W band |
| M-36 | Lower grade; easier to stamp, lower silicon | 0.47, 0.64 mm | Appliance motors, cost-driven stampings | Economy 50W / 65W band |
The thicknesses above follow the three ASTM A677 gauge bands, about 0.36, 0.47 and 0.64 mm. Within each band the standard lists seven to nine types by maximum core loss at 60 Hz and 1.5 T, tested by the Epstein method.

Why the Standard Dropped the M Designation
Current ASTM A677 grades are designated by their maximum core loss and thickness, the same logic used in EN 10106 and the Chinese W system. This makes the loss requirement readable straight off the grade name, which is why the old type labels were retired. The magnetic properties themselves did not disappear; they were re-expressed in the loss-based naming.
Practically, this means a modern supplier rarely stocks a coil labelled M-27. What they can supply is a current grade whose measured loss and polarization meet the requirement the old M-27 was chosen for. The available CRNGO grades show how the current range is organised by loss level rather than by type label.

How to Match an Old M Grade to a Current One
Do not match by the M name alone. Three pieces of information from the drawing decide the replacement:
- The gauge on the old lamination, because the same M type in two thicknesses does not carry the same loss figure.
- Core loss requirement.The maximum watts per kilogram at the stated induction and frequency, usually 1.5 T and 50 or 60 Hz.
- Polarisation requirement.The minimum induction at the stated field, where the design depends on a high B50 rather than a low loss.
With those three figures, look up the current grade in ASTM A677, EN 10106 or GB/T 2521.1 that meets or beats all three. A grade that matches loss but falls short on polarization is not a substitute, and vice versa. Selecting non-oriented steel for motors follows the same loss-and-polarisation check.
What to Check on the Mill Certificate
When the replacement arrives, the certificate should carry the current grade designation, the measured specific total loss at the test point, the minimum polarization and the actual thickness. If the certificate only repeats the old M label without measured values, the substitution has not been verified.
One more point for high-speed or traction designs: an old M grade was usually specified for 50 or 60 Hz service. Reusing it in a 400 Hz machine needs a fresh loss check at that frequency; the 50 Hz figure does not transfer. The non-oriented steel used in EV motors is the thin-gauge end of that requirement.
FAQ
Can M-19 and M-27 be swapped? Only if the measured loss and polarization of the M-27 replacement meet the M-19 requirement. The labels alone do not authorise the swap.
Is M-36 grain-oriented steel? No. All four grades here are non-oriented. Grain-oriented steel belongs to a separate ASTM specification and a different grade system.
The supplier quoted 50W470 against an M-27 drawing. Is that acceptable? Check the drawing’s loss and polarization limits against the 50W470 data sheet at the design induction and frequency. If both meet the limits, the substitution is defensible; if not, move to a higher grade.
Are these M grades still produced? Some North American and Asian mills still list them for replacement demand, but most new production uses the loss-based designations. Availability should be confirmed before the drawing is locked.
Have an old motor drawing that calls out an M grade? Send the grade, thickness and the loss or induction figures on the nameplate to vera.liang@ztwysteel.com, and we will match it to a current designation before the order is placed.